February 20th is National Cherry Pie Day. While the dish is credited to Queen Elizabeth the 1st of England, most Americans are more likely to think of George Washington and his cherry tree when thinking of this bubbly, tart dessert.
Little known is that the story of George Washington and his cherry tree is a complete fabrication. That didn’t stop many people from making paintings, decorative plates, and desserts around this famous fiction.
I wouldn’t know a tenth of what I do about pie making and baking in general if it weren’t for King Arthur Flour.
America’s oldest flour company is also the one I trust with every baking question I have had in the past or will ever have in the future. They broke me of my pie crust curse after a weekend at their Blog and Bake conference last June. When they asked for my help celebrating National Cherry Pie Day, I couldn’t possibly say no.
For National Cherry Pie Day I adapted KAF’s Presidential Cherry Pie recipe. So far we haven’t seen sour cherries down here in Texas, so I used sweet Bing cherries. Just as delicious, and deeply seductive, this is one cherry pie you’ll want to make again and again.
Homemade pie filling couldn’t be easier with King Arthur Flour’s Pie Filling Enhancer. In fact, it took me longer to pit the cherries (who would have thought I’d miss that little uni-tasker down here in Texas?) than it did to make the pie filling.

The pie baked up into perfection in just 35 minutes. Word of warning: when baking in a foreign oven, trust your instincts. KAF’s recipe calls for 40-45 minutes in the oven. I learned the hard way during the baking of this cherry pie that my sister’s oven runs 10 degrees hotter than the temperature on the display, resulting in an overdone edge – even WITH the fabulous silicone crust protector provided by KAF. That crust protector can only do so much – it’s not going to protect the pie when you bake it 10 minutes too long.
But I should have known better. I read King Arthur Flour’s The Baking Sheet on a regular basis, and they always recommend testing your oven with a separate oven thermometer, instead of trusting the display. If you’ve never heard of it, The Baking Sheet is King Arthur Flour’s bi-monthly newsletter, filled with 24 pages of recipes, tips, tricks, and all the secrets to baking you’d ever want to know. It’s edited by Susan Reid, whom I have personally met and baked with. She knows her stuff, I can tell you that much.
If you want to get in the know about all things baking, I highly recommend picking up a subscription. They even have a special deal going on right now – if you choose the special offer, you get a 1 year subscription PLUS every issue of The Baking Sheet since 2009!

Check out the giveaway below the printable recipe!
Presidential Cherry Pie
Adapted from King Arthur Flour
Ingredients
One prepared double pie crust, or your favorite pie crust recipe
5-6 cups fresh Bing Cherries
3/4 cup sugar
3/4 teaspoon cinnamon
1/4 cup Pie Filling Enhancer (see King Arthur Flour’s site for substitutes)
1 teaspoon almond extract
1/2 teaspoon salt
Directions
Preheat the oven to 425F.
Prepare and roll out the bottom half of the pie crust. Line the pie dish with the dough. Prepare the pie filling.
Wash and pit the Bing cherries. In a medium bowl, combine cherries, 1/2 cup of cold water, sugar, cinnamon, and pie filling enhancer. Stir gently until all ingredients appear well mixed.
Add almond extract and salt, and stir again.
Pour pie filling into the pie dish.
To make a lattice pie, use a pizza cutter to slice strips into the top crust. Start with the smallest edge, and lay it towards the edge, where both ends of the strip will touch the bottom pie crust edge.
Continue lining the pie, using an over-under basket weave technique to line the pie.
Pinch and fold over the bottom crust overhang to secure the ends of each strip, then use your fingers and thumb to create a decorative edge (or use a fork to press an edge into the crust).
Cover the edge of the pie with a silicone baking shield or aluminum foil.
Brush milk onto pie crust strips and sprinkle with sparkling sugar if desired.
Bake for 35-45 minutes, until pie crust is golden brown and filling is slightly bubbling.
Allow to cool and enjoy with vanilla ice cream or whipped cream!
To Celebrate National Cherry Pie Day King Arthur Flour is offering one lucky B&B reader a fabulous Pie Package!
King Arthur Flour Pie Package
Here’s what you have to do:
To get extra entries, you can:
You must leave a comment here telling me you tweeted.
Important Details:
-This giveaway is open to USA residents only and will run until Monday, February 27th at 11:59 am EST.
-Winner(s) will be generated via a random number generator software program. Winner will be notified via the contact email provided on the comment contact form.
-Winner(s) will have until 2/29/12 to claim their King Arthur Flour Pie Package or we will choose another winner.
-Winner will receive (1) issue of The Baking Sheet, (1) 5 lb. bag of King Arthur Unbleached All Purpose Flour, (1) package of King Arthur Flour Pie Filling Enhancer, (1) Adjustable Silicone Pie Crust Shield, and (1) King Arthur Flour Pie Essentials DVD {Valued at over $50}. Product will be shipped by King Arthur Flour.
Disclosure:
This giveaway is provided to you by King Arthur Flour. The views and opinions expressed by Amber Bracegirdle on Bluebonnets & Brownies are my own, and based upon my experiences with King Arthur Flour products. I received the giveaway items for review free of charge.
Pin It










{ 212 comments }
I’m sad to say I’ve never had a homemade cherry pie, but I’m sure that would probably be my favorite! I’ve had store-bought cherry pies before that were delicious, but I’d love to try making one on my own sometime! Thanks for the giveaway!
I follow KAF on facebook
I follow B&B on facebook
I follow you on Pinterest
I’ve never made a cherry pie either because most of my family aren’t cherry pie fans (apple is their favorite). I did have a bite of a great cherry pie at a restaurant in St. Louis (my home town) — many many years ago. I love King Arthur.
I follow king arthur and bluebonnets on twitter @icywit and tweeted the giveaway/
I like King Arthur on FB.
I like you on FB.
I follow you on pinterest!
Best homemade cherry pie I have ever had is my mother-in-laws. It is amazing and I strive to make a pie almost as good as hers. I know my husband would be thrilled to have more pie!
I’ve never had a cherry pie I didn’t like! :)
I follow king arthur and bluebonnets on twitter @basilesocial and tweeted the giveaway
While I’m not a cherry pie fan, I DO love a blueberry pie. My favorite comes from the state fair.
Do you guys ever get sour cherries in Texas? In NJ, they don’t come into season until late June – this year, you should come cherry picking with me! I have one bag left from the summer bounty in my freezer, so maybe I’ll make some mini pies today.
My favorite Cherry Pie is this 5 ingredient recipe: http://onecurlyfryinaboxoftheregular.com/2011/07/08/5-ingredient-friday-cherry-pie/
I follow Bluebonnets & Brownies on Facebook!
I follow Bluebonnets & Brownies on Pinterest
I like KAF on Facebook
This pie looks awesome! I’ve never had a good cherry pie…so sad.
I like a cherry pie that’s heavy on the crust. And I love King Arthur!
Love sweet cherry pie…a little less on the tart side. Yum!
I follow you on Facebook.
honestly, i’ve never had a winner of a cherry pie. never had a homemade one and never really liked the cloying sweetness and goopyness of the store bought ones. i may have to remedy that soon!!
i follow you both on twitter and i tweeted the giveaway
i like you on facebook
i like KA on facebook
and i now follow your boards on pinterest :)
My most favorite Cherry pie is my mom’s. She makes her crust with nuts rolled in it and a struesel topping . It is so good,
I follow you on FB
The best cherry pie I ever had was my grandmother’s, back when she still lived in this house that had a huge cherry tree in the backyard. Heaven.
I tweeted @KingArthurFlour and @BluebonnetBaker on Twitter.
Enter to win a Pie Package for National Cherry Pie Day from @KingArthurFlour & @BluebonnetBaker! http://su.pr/6sCXR1 #giveaway
I already like KAF on FB
The absolute *best* cherry pie I’ve ever had were the ones my late paternal grandmother, Thelma Herrmann, baked with her own home canned cherries used in the filling. She also used this shortening that I don’t believe you can get anymore. She told me that since it didn’t have preservatives/stabilizers it couldn’t be sold in the South (it melted into liquid ?). I can’t for the life of me remember the brand, but this was about 30 years ago (or more).
I follow Bluebonnets & Brownies on Fbook.
Sad to say, even though Cherry is my favorite pie, I couldn’t say when or where I had one last. Noone else in my house eats it. After seeing these pics, if we weren’t snowed in, I might would make one today.
I follow KA on FB, that’s how I found B&B
Now I follow B&B on FB
And I now follow B&B on Pinterest
My great-aunt Lil made a mean cherry pie so I’d have to say that’s my favorite! Thanks for this giveaway…you have turned me into a big fan of KAF!
(PS: I am a US citizen and have US address even though I’m currently overseas.)
I tweeted about this giveaway.
And I’m now following you on pinterest!
The one and only cherry pie I’ve made is probably my favorite. Only because the only other time I’ve had it was in a cheesy diner in Orange County when I was a kid. If a pie is too sickeningly sweet for a 10 year old to eat it? You know it’s bad. ;p
I follow on twitter and tweeted the giveaway
I like King Arthur Flour on Facebook
I like BB&B on facebook
I follow you on pinterest!
Best cherry pie ever was my Grandma’s. She is gone now and I miss her so but I have been trying to make pies just like her!!
Also…I’m now following KAF on facebook…
And B&B! Thanks again for the giveaway!
(And, yes…my US address is fine! Thanks!)
I follow you on Facebook!
I follow you on Pinterest!
I follow King Arthur Flour on Facebook.
My grandma’s cherry pie was the best.
I am following you and King Arthur and tweeted https://twitter.com/#!/rusthawk/status/171649742542082048
I follow King Arthur on facebook (Rust Hawk).
I am one of your facebook followers (Rust Hawk).
I love cherry pie! AH! My fave was a slice I had at a little Ma-and-Pops restaurant when I was in college. So yummy!
I like KAF on fb!
I’m a fan of yours on fb!
I like any cherr y pie.
I follow KAF on FB.
The best Cherry Pie I ever had was one I baked myself. My sister-in-law brought me cherries from her cherry tree, they were very tiny and sour and took forever to pit. However, once I did that and cooked the filling and baked the pie, it turned out amazing. I strongly dislike the commercial cherry pie filling you can buy in the store so I was really hesitant to waste the sugar, flour and lard to make this pie, but am really glad that I did.
I make a really good Cherry Pie using cherries from Trader Joes.
I follow KAF on FB
I can’t remember ever eating a cherry pie I didn’t like. My earliest memories of cherry pie was the cherry cobbler we had in our school lunchrooms. Yum.
I am following you on Pinterest (my newest addiction)!!
I follow you on FB…
I follow you and King Arthur Flour on Twitter and tweeted about the giveaway. @sebh55
I follow King Arthur Flour on FB.
I follow you on FB.
I’m now following you on Pinterest.
Best cherry pie was an apple and sour cherry pie with a rustic crust. I got the recipe from a Red Sage cookbook several years ago. Yummmm!
I’m sad to say that I’ve never baked a cherry pie and have only had the store bakery variety, which pale in comparison to the picture of yours. My dad loves cherry pie and I think I’ll have to print your recipe and give it a try for his 85th birthday. Seems the perfect way to celebrate an All-American WWII vet.
The best cherry pie I ever had, was one made following Marcia Adams recipe from Cooking from Quilt Country.
My favorite cherry pie is one my mom makes. It has a cheesecake layer on the bottom and cherries on the top–so good. But yours looks scrumptous too!
I follow both on twitter @sharonjo2
Tweet: https://twitter.com/#!/sharonjo2/status/171666320230846464
I follow King Arthur Flour on facebook.
(Sharon O.)
I follow Bluebonnets & Brownies on facebook.
(Sharon O.)
I follow you on Pinterest.
(Sharon O.)
Oh goodness, where to begin? I grew up in Northern Michigan and we pride ourselves on our cherries. I miss them here in Connecticut. But everyone there made the best cherry pie, if ya know what I mean. Grandma’s was the best, but we would always make an annual trip up to Traverse City to The Cherry Hut during The Cherry Festival to eat and get several pies to go as well. But living here in NE has changed my perspective on flour and now only use King Arthur. When I was growing up in MI, we never even heard of KA flour, so I am now drooling over the thought of KA flour and Michigan cherries. Maybe I will get out there this summer and bring along some KA as well.
I tweeted the message :)
I follow KAF on Facebook
I follow Bluebonnets and Brownies on Facebook
The best cherry pie I had was one I made where I made my own crust and pitted fresh cherries.
I follow B&B on FB
I follow B&B on Pintrest
I follow King Arthur Flour on FB
I follow you on FB.
Follow you both on Twitter and tweeted: https://twitter.com/#!/GoddessFoodie/status/171671842501836800
I follow you on Pinterest.
I have been lucky to be able to find fresh sour cherries for a couple weeks each summer, so the best cherry pies I’ve had are the ones I’ve made myself!
The best cherry pie will always be the one my best friend made for me when I’d had a really awful day.
I followed you and KAF on FB!
My moms is the best I have had! lilsis_75@hotmail.com
My favorite cherry pie was one I had at a party a few years ago. Thanks for the giveaway.
I follow King Arthur Flour on Facebook. I love their flour.
I follow Bluebonnets & Brownies on Facebook.
The best cherry pie I ever had was a simple conconction I made from a pate brise, fresh local cherries, raw sugar, and a splash of lemon juice. I made tarts in a cupcake tin and they were gone before they ever made it to the event they were intended for.
My Nanny’s pie is pretty darn good. But girl, this looks amazing!
FB too!
My sister made a cherry pie a few years ago for Thanksgiving. She used a homemade crust and canned cherry pie filling, which I usually don’t like. But this was the best cherry pie I’d ever eaten, so I had to know which brand of filling she used. The problem? She couldn’t remember and the trash had already been picked up. I’ve been heartbroken ever since.
I’ve had some real stinkers! I’ve had some almost good ones. Hopefully, I shall find the perfect one someday:)
I like you FB
I like king Arthur too:) I went to their store this past winter!
Follow you on pinterest
The best cherry pie I’ve ever had was at a small mom and daughter coffee shop in western Kansas. It was cherry-rhubarb and fantastic.
Some cherry hand-pies I made awhile back were probably my fave (I’m partial to my own crust).
Hmm.. overdue to made some again :)
The best cherry pie I had was when my sister had a cherry tree and made a pie from the fresh cherries.
The best cherry pie i’ve ever had was my own! I made it this past Thanksgiving. It was to die for.
I am following King Arthur and Blue Bonnets on Twitter.
I tweeted about the giveaway
https://twitter.com/#!/sandyb720/status/171741404463247360
The best cherry pie I have ever had is the one my Grandma Dicks used to make. She had a bakery and boy could she ever bake. Yum!!!!!
I tweeted the giveaway!
I’m following Bluebonnets & Baker on Facebook.
I’m following King Arthur Flour on Facebook!
I follow King Arthur on Facebook. Thank you for the giveaway!
This is the best cherry pie! http://housetohaus.blogspot.com/2011/06/cherry-tree.html
I follow Bluebonnie and Brownie on Facebook. Thank you for the giveaway!
I follow Bluebonnet on Pinterest!
My mom’s was the best, of course. She grew up on a farm, and often made pies then. Our neighbors here had a cherry tree, and we picked cherries each year and she made pie.
The best cherry pie I ever had; had a oatmeal streusel topping and a flaky bottom crust. It was a sweet with just the right amount of tartness.
I follow @KingArthurFlour and @BluebonnetBaker on twitter and tweeted
I follow King Arthur Flour on Facebook.
I follow Bluebonnets & Brownies on Facebook.
I follow BluebonnetBaker on Pinterest.
This might sound weird, but I don’t think I’ve ever had cherry pie. Lots of apple pie in my lifetime, but never cherry. But now I’m definitely intrigued as to what I’ve been missing!
I follow Bluebonnets & Brownies on FB
I follow King Arthur on FB
I follow BlueBonnet Baker on Pininterest
I remember having a pretty a cherry pie at a truckstop somewhere in Arizona on a cross country trip to California. The cherries probably came out of a jar but I remember the crust didn’t taste like cardboard.Which is pretty unusual so it stuck in my head.. Never had homemade cherry pie.
I didn’t know today is national cherry pie day, but man does this pie look amazing! I wish I had a huge slice of it right now!
My grandma used to make the best cherry pie and every other kind of pie. Pie was her favorite thing to bake.
yikes…I forgot to change my email on the my post at 9:49. This one has my correct email address.
I am a Bluebonnets and Brownies facebook fan
I am a KAF facebook fan
I follow you on pinterest
SCORE I now get to follow you on Pinterest! I follow you and KAF on Facebook and Twitter, I tweeted about the giveaway PLUS I pinned it LOL CUZ I LOVE me some Cherry Pie (and I have three jars of cherries I canned this summer from my mom’s trees left and just made some pie crusts last night… yummy cherry pie) my tweet can be found here – https://twitter.com/#!/AKMamma/status/171797262375202816
THANKS for EVERYTHING you share with us wanna be foodie bloggers!
Loved olleberry and cherry pie that I had at a shower this pass summer
The first one I ever made when I was 22 and living all on my own for the first time :)
Best cherry pie I had was one I made following a recipe out of “Baking Illustrated” cookbook.
I tweeted about the giveaway!
I follow King Arthur Flour on facebook.
I follow you on facebook!
I followed you on Pinterest!
My favorite pie is the pie I make for my daughter, to honor her request for a cherry pie for her birthday since her birthday is December 29th I had to use frozen cherries. She loved it so much that I make it every year for her birthday.
The best cherry pie I ever had was at a diner in college. I’d love to try and recreate that.
I follow you on Pinterest.
I follow you on facebook.
I follow King Arthur Flour on facebook.
Following you on Pinterest – and trying to learn the ins and outs there. Just signed up – need more coffee to figure this out!
The best cherry pie I’ve ever had is one that my mother-in-law made with fresh cherries from one of our neighbor’s tree when she was visiting after our son was born. She is an awesome cook and baker, and has given me a lot of incentive to keep practicing! Something about that sweet and tart deep cherry flavored goodness that just can’t be recreated from commercially canned or frozen cherries. To this day, cherry pie is my favorite and is always my birthday dessert. The crowning glory is KAF sparkling sugar sprinkled on the top before baking. Makes it more beautiful and gives the crisp-flaky crust and extra crunch that is unbeatable!
I follow King Arthur Flour on Facebook (and have for some time!)
I follow Bluebonnets and Brownies on Facebook.
My best cherry pie was one I made with cherries that I picked myself. I went a little crazy with cherries last summer and picked tons of them.
This is a great giveaway! I love KAF so much. It’s the only kind of flour that I’ll bake with. I hope to attend one of their classes in Vermont sometime this year.
I follow King Arthur Flour on Facebook.
I follow Blue Bonnets and Brownies on Facebook.
I also follow you on Pinterest!
I had a slice of cherry pie when we were traveling through Michigan that was bar far the best I have ever had. I can’t remember the restaurant (more like a nice not-so-greasy diner), but I’m salivating just thinking about it. I typically ordered cherry pie when I could because my mom never made it. My older brother didn’t like cherry pie so the rest of us would suffer. Darn them siblings.
I like you on FB
I like KAF on FB
GORGEOUS pie, Amber! I loved meeting you at KAF for Blog and Bake – I agree there is nowhere better to learn to beat the fear of pie dough! :)
my aunt made a great cherry pie when I was a child I always looked forward to family gatherings as she would bring some!
Cathy B*****y pbprojecthope at yahoodotcom
following King Arthur flour on FB!
Cathy B*****Y pbprojecthope at yahoodotcom
following you on FB! would love the followback!
Cathy B*****y pbprojecthope at yahoodotcom
Following BlueBonnetBaker on Pinterest. my id is Cathy B*****y.. would love the followback! Thank you!
Cathy B*****Y pbprojecthope at yahoodotcom
sadly, I can’t even remember when the last time was that I had cherry pie. Obviously, I need to make your recipe & remedy that! The cherry pie that stands out in my memory is the one I used to get at the Spanish bakery I went to with my grandmother as a child in Puerto Rico — La Ceiba. Their pastry cases were a child’s dream!!!
I follow Bluebonnets & Brownies on FB
I follow you on Pinterest
I follow KAF on Facebook
I can’t remember ever having a homemade cherry pie. Though I got a cherry pitter for my birthday last year, so I’ll have to try your recipe. Most other ones call for canned cherries, so I’m glad yours uses fresh.
Can you believe I’ve never had cherry pie!
I never met a cherry pie I didn’t like! It’s my very favorite type of pie.
I “like” KAF on Facebook
I “like” you on Facebook
I followed you on Pinterest
My favorite cherry pie has a crumble crust!
I follow like KAF on Facebook
I like you on Facebook
I tweeted about the giveaway @ambersconfctns
My favorite pie is Mary Anderson’s. She works with me – and her pie is legendary!
I follow Bluebonnets and Brownies on FB
I also follow King Arthur Flour on FB
I love cherry pie…it is one of my favorites. I hope this will count as anadditional entry as I am refusing to participate in all of these social networks programs. I feel it just takes away face time with my family and friends, which I feel is much more important. I would sit with a friend or family over a cup of tea or coffee and a piece of cherry pie (or any other pie for that matter!)and catch up on each others lives. To me those are really the moments that count. Cherrypie and friends and family!
at a fair!
The only cherry pies I’ve had in US were made with that awful canned stuff. And I’m not surprised, the cherries here are hard to come by. I was born in Eastern Europe, and we had different varieties of cherries. The sour ones were best for cooking. My mom made all kinds of goodies from preserves to varenikys, to crumbles and tarts.
And I followed KA on twitter
And you on FB and Pinterest.
The best cherry pie I’ve ever had was one made by my Aunt on a Thanksgiving a few years ago when all of our family members can gather together for a feast. I think food always tastes better when shared with love ones.
amy [at] utry [dot] it
Tweeted about this giveaway: https://twitter.com/#!/uTry_it/status/172242556875313152
amy [at] utry [dot] it
tweeted: https://twitter.com/#!/uTry_it/status/172242556875313152
amy [at] utry [dot] it
Following King Arthur Flour on Facebook
amy [at] utry [dot] it
Following Bluebonnets & Brownies on Facebook
amy [at] utry [dot] it
Following BluebonnetBaker on Pinterest! I’m so glad I did. Love your boards!
amy [at] utry [dot] it
I’ve only had cherry pie once, at a friend’s house (she is a trained chef). It was fantastic, but I realized that I’m still quite allergic to cherries even after they have been cooked so I have sworn off cherry pies. (I’m mildly allergic to a lot of fruits – cooking them usually takes removes the allergen for me.)
My favorite pie has to be a Cherry Cheese Pie made by my godmother (it’s a yummy cream cheese based pie)!
Oh, and I liked you on Facebook :)
My mom used to make a cherry pie every Thanksgiving and Christmas, but it was always made with canned cherry filling. It was tasty but too sweet for me. I’ve never tried making my own cherry pie from scratch but your recipe has inspired me!
I like Bluebonnets & Brownies on Facebook.
I can’t even remember when I last had cherry pie. It’s been so long…What I do remember is that it was not homemade, so I would love to try to make my own some day.
Sadly, I don’t know if I’ve ever had cherry pie!
I follow you both and tweeted
I like KAF on Facebook
I like you on Facebook
I follow you on Pinterest
The best cherry pies were the ones my grandmother made when I was growing up. Her cherries were picked from a tree in her orchard and the pies were wonderful.
I make cherry pie every year for my husband’s birthday. He doesn’t care for cake, but loves cherry pie. I always use the recipe on the can of cherries. The best one? They all turn out pretty good. I’ve been wanting to try KAF’s pie enhancer. That might turn them from pretty good to great.
I “liked” you on Facebook, and I already like KAF over there.
ive actually never had a cherry pie! i think it’s because i’m not a huuge fan of cherries hm i do like a good mixed berry crumble though! :)
i like you on fbook!
i like KAF on fbook !
i follow you on pinterest!
My best cherry pie is the Triple Cherry Pie from the cherry spoon in Traverse City. So good!
I like KAF on facebook
I like B&B on facebook!
The best cherry pie I’ve ever had was quite a few years ago and it had a cinnamon streusel topping.
OH YUM! This looks divine Amber!
Comments on this entry are closed.